Jump to content
SportsWrath

Derek Carr.


BlueInCanada
 Share

Recommended Posts

Why though? Behind what oline? Why fuck up your relationship with the guy behind center who hasnt missed a game since we drafted him... the man whos been a class act through and through? And why fuck your chance to draft your next franchise qb with a few meaningless wins..

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why though? Behind what oline? Why fuck up your relationship with the guy behind center who hasnt missed a game since we drafted him... the man whos been a class act through and through? And why fuck your chance to draft your next franchise qb with a few meaningless wins..

 

Because you then dont have to draft a franchise QB for a while and rebuild with him and actually field some competitive teams.

 

You still use your first round pick and even trade a guy for another to build the Oline.

 

What do people want on this team? A QB who isnt regressing and a Oline.

 

What can they do when they trade for Carr and draft the best Oline player with their first round pick?

 

Solve both problems.

 

What do they do if they draft a rookie with the first and use the second on an Oline player?

 

Get a rookie QB sitting behind Eli/some FA Vet/Tanney, and a not as impact Oline player.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Because you then dont have to draft a franchise QB for a while and rebuild with him and actually field some competitive teams.

 

You still use your first round pick and even trade a guy for another to build the Oline.

 

What do people want on this team? A QB who isnt regressing and a Oline.

 

What can they do when they trade for Carr and draft the best Oline player with their first round pick?

 

Solve both problems.

 

What do they do if they draft a rookie with the first and use the second on an Oline player?

 

Get a rookie QB sitting behind Eli/some FA Vet/Tanney, and a not as impact Oline player.

You think Carr is the answer?

 

And you want to deny the team and fans the benefit of an exciting young QB who wont blow a whole in your cap?

 

And again... what do you do with Eli?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You think Carr is the answer?

 

And you want to deny the team and fans the benefit of an exciting young QB who wont blow a whole in your cap?

 

And again... what do you do with Eli?

 

Why isnt Carr the answer?

 

So you're saying a young exciting player (and mobile) QB like Carr who doesnt have a cap higher than Eli's isnt going to excite the fans?

 

And what has Eli done at all to warrant staying in the line up? People were calling for him to be benched for fucking Webb last year, what's the difference for benching for Carr? Nothing. People want change, this is change in a positive way.

 

Keeping Eli in the starting line up accomplishes nothing, actually trading for a guy you think you can win with so he can start learning the ins and out before the off season, why not?

 

lol this board was screaming for Eli to be benched in every game day thread, yet you mention an actual change for it "OHHHH NOOOOO THE DRAFT POSITION AND ELIS PRIDE!!!!"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not my favorite route to take seeing as how hes paid and i am not sure what his ceiling is at this point, but fuck it if they did it Id get on board. These skill position guys are being wasted right now

Thats what Im saying and I think drafting your next franchise qb and benefiting from his rookie contract not to mention him, barkley, Engram, and ODB will florish together....

 

Carr Im not sure of... strikes me like that qb we had in sb 2000... Collins.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thats what Im saying and I think drafting your next franchise qb and benefiting from his rookie contract not to mention him, barkley, Engram, and ODB will florish together....

 

Carr Im not sure of... strikes me like that qb we had in sb 2000... Collins.

In the grand scheme of things, Collins was good value for us considering how we got him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not for nothing, but didn't Carr just sign a gazillion-dollar contract? I know his cap hit for the year is 25 mil but not sure how much of that we'd have to eat.

Wed be responsible for base salary and the non-signing bonuses like workout and roster and shit like that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm curious why you say this. He worked with one of the greatest ever - Rich Gannon

 

He's known as this "QB guru" yet when he was in TB he didnt develop a single QB there to anything more then a couple year starter, despite drafting and acquiring numerous young QBs.

 

King, Simms, Griese(sp), Johnson, who else? Grada something.

 

He hit gold with Gannon with the Raiders but has never followed it up with the same performance in the slightest.

 

Now he's running Carr out of town, and will probably draft another QB and destroy his career as well.

 

I just never understood why Gruden has been known as a "QB" coach when it's arguably the worst performance out of any position when he's been the HC of a team.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah Carr will be 28 by next season, Justin Herbert 21. Give me Herbert

 

Just watched Herbert closely for the first time tonight, in his loss against Wash. St.

 

He'll definitely be a very high pick. Reminds me a ton of Josh Allen, a bit more slightly built, almost the same kind of arm strength. More arm talent though, he was getting the ball out accurately at all arm angles, with wacky feet positioning - in terms of the 2018 QB class, in that respect he's more like Darnold.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...