With a ROY candidate though. When Cruz played like Beckham the Giants won the SB. Gilbride was top 10, top 5 a few times, when teams were setting records. I get that McAdoo gets a pass because it's first year but Gilbride gets throwen under the bus when he had to deal with the same shit. The fact of the matter is that Gilbride is a good OC but had to deal with a lack of talent, just like McAdoo. IMHO the offense would have been a lot more explosive with Gilbride this year.