NightFire

Definitely but that's not a negative. Stability is what builds great teams.

Just waiting until 5 seconds to snap the ball with 2 minutes left would have won the Giants 4 games or more. When your D is struggling having 30 second drives is a disaster. This is the same issue Kelley caused with the Eagles.

Stretching...probably.

In a few years we all won't be. Sad day my friends.

Isn't this the list for all teams needing a coach (except McAdoo)?

Reese has been decent in the draft. It's the FA signings that have been terrible. Has there been one good FA signing in the Reese era?

IMHO Coughlin should stay as coach for as long as he wishes to coach.

Because he was too harsh; being benched for 5 minutes late is ridiculous. There has to be a middle ground and OBJ deserved to be benched after the second ULC penalty what to speak of the third. It's clear that the patients are running the asylum here and that will probably be what is going to cost Coughlin his job.

True enough and that's why I am on the fence with Coughlin. Cruz doesn't play, JPP blows up hand, OBJ goes full on retard and is suspended, season starting LBs and TEs out and Eli forgets you can snap with 1 second left multiple times. This has been trying to shine a turd. Without Coughlin and these coaches I firmly believe the Giants would be thinking about the number 1 pick.

Would be nice to have one of those or two.

I was going to ask about this. Here's hoping the Giants Eagles game matters.

This has been a season for the ages. Everything that can go wrong has gone wrong.

Yeah, the guy has some real emotional maturity issues. He did seem to really calm down during the almost comeback. I think he may have realised he was going to far.

Really? You're telling me that Collins and Meriweather were better starting safety options than Rolle and Collins? Pass me a hit of whatever you're smoking. The fact of the matter is that the Giants have completely botched the safety position (and LB, and TE).

Would be nice to have Rolle right about now.

That one hurt. He could have been the steal of the draft like Mathieu. Well we did get Moore in third round that year so...

I think the Panthers will bring pressure so there is no time for Eli to play pitch and catch with OBJ. This is why Vereen would be great this week if the Giants can remember he exists. Some quick dumps to slow the pass rush and Eli time for those big OBJ plays.

Or decade. He's was being talked about as the number 1 draft pick and once in a generation talent. Not saying the Giants shouldn't try drafting a LB in the first round of these years but using Mack as an example is disingenuous. Also Mack doesn't play as a LB anymore as pointed out.

Yeah, with the weak OLine you would think he'd get a lot of screens out of the backfield but nothing. Sometimes I forget he's on the team. Reading the 1998 thread makes me pine for those 21 yard TD throws to a RB (Barber).

Well...in that case McAdoo is slightly redeemed. Makes me wonder though why Vereen is getting almost nothing. Is he also injured?

Benched after the fumble. I do feel bad because he did look dejected but it's best player plays. This series I think encapsulates our frustration with the Giants play calling: 1-15-NYG 5 (5:41) 23-R.Jennings up the middle to NYG 16 for 11 yards (20-R.Jones). 2-4-NYG 16 (5:09) 23-R.Jennings right guard to NYG 19 for 3 yards (20-R.Jones). 3-1-NYG 19 (4:40) 23-R.Jennings up the middle to NYG 20 for 1 yard (97-J.Phillips). 1-10-NYG 20 (3:59) 44-A.Williams left tackle to NYG 25 for 5 yards (24-Br.McCain). 2-5-NYG 25 (3:23) (No Huddle, Shotgun) PENALTY on MIA-93-N.Suh, Defensive Offside, 4 yards, enforced at NYG 25 - No Play. 2-1-NYG 29 (3:06) (Shotgun) 10-E.Manning FUMBLES (Aborted) at NYG 25, RECOVERED by MIA-20-R.Jones at NYG 34. 20-R.Jones to NYG 25 for 9 yards (86-J.Cunningham). Jennings has a great run and they sit him. Why would Williams get another 2 carries after Jennings is running strong? The main reason why Jennings should be getting the load is because he rarely has negative yards. If there is nothing he'll just smash himself into the pile and gain a yard.

Carolina is going to rape this D. Our starting LBs are Brinkley, Thomas and some guy. DLine had Kuhn starting with a guy that blew half his hand off (although I will give JPP credit for giving 100%) and starting safety is Dahl and rookie Collins. Let that sink in and think about a run heavy Carolina team. I feel bad for Spagnuolo because he's trying to shine a turd every week.

The turnaround moment of the game is when Williams dropped the ball. Fucking McAdoo is clueless.

This is why IF the Giants make the playoffs they could easily go on a run to the SB again. The majority of those loses were very winnable.