like I said, he's a phenomenal talent. youd have to be an complete jackass to think Jeter was going to be a young player forever and that nobody else would ever be a great shortstop to play in NY. Its just a matter of opinion, theres no wrong or right answer....Yankees fans will say Jeter, Mets fan will say Reyes...this horse has been beaten to death, beaten after its beean dead, then shot, stabbed, burned, sodomized, decapitated, electrocuted...you see whre Im going.......... bottom line theyre top players at their positions and any other team would love to have either one of them.