Of course Eli is overpaid. Do you know who else is overpaid? EVERYBODY. Unless you find the cure for cancer, you're not worth 103 mil, I don't care how far you throw a football.
Now, if Eli is such a horrible QB, name the QB in our division you'd rather have. How about in our Conference? When I go down the list, I come up with three guys in the LEAGUE I'd rather have (Brees, Brady, and Peyton), a few guys that are maybe a push, and none that are head and shoulders above the guy we've got. Cutler, Rivers, and Rapistbergers are hotheads that would never cut it under the NYC spotlight... the idea that somehow a clown like Cutler is more clutch than Eli (who made a Super Bowl play you're going to be watching for the rest of your life) is laughable.
I don't remember Phil Simms ever chewing out his teammates, and I've been going to Giants games for 25+ years. He and Parcells got into some famous yelling matches, but I doubt he ever told anyone on his team to "shape up or ship out." On a team with Lawrence Taylor he didn't really have to.