BlueInCanada

I briefly remember that. But yeah I thought it was some YouTube Cowboys fan.

Look at Penix, if he played any other position in the NFL. RB, WR, CB, Dline, Oline and he was coming out college after three season ending injuries and one good/great year. A team wouldn't even think about touching him till day three. The guy might end up top 5 lol

As I've said QBs are now a "FUCK IT" take the risk position. Guys who would normally be second round/third round picks are now going high in the top 10. Teams need a QB to compete with Mahomes magic, because you arent going to win against Mahomes with even a good QB.

Also hopefully this is just some massive smoke screen to get the Vikings to overpay the farm to the Cardinals so they panic trade and get JJ. Instead of the Cards possibly taking a WR the Giants want.

Fucking gross. Just stay put and draft him then, he is not going top 4 unless the Giants go full retard. And as a white dude playing a black dude once said, you never go ful retard.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NFCEastMemeWar/s/wGHYoygwh5

Good for a laugh with some of these Charger/Eli takes.

Both of these gentlemen were greats. Back when the Giants were fun to watch every weekend lol

Who? lol

My only issue is Maye, just looks like he'll need a stacked team to supper him. But just IMO.

The QBs are typically ranked lower than these other guys on most mocks. Their value is inflated by being a QB. Is what I'm getting at.

I guess depending on where you read your draft news from they could be ranked lower. But this is how ESPN and Mad Mel have the prospects ranked. https://www.espn.com/nfl/draft/bestavailable Alt is #5 Nabers and the WRs are well above McCathy. I dunno guess it just depends.

Personal opinion? Cause I haven't heard these hot cakes yet.

And it's a shame there really isn't a franchise QB to be had IMO that is going to fall into our lap. Unless we trade for Daniels or something. Giants FO should of just tanked the season by trading away Barkley or what not. But thems the breaks. Never know though Shcoen is a fucking mad man so maybe we do go after one of the high end QBs.

Just the last good FB we've had. God I miss that TD dance.

Probably not if we are starting Lock next year, which who knows at this point with Jones recovery. Or whenever they put Jones back out there only for him to go back on IR and cost.us 40 million dollars in cap the year after. Then Mara fires everyone. Or they take a rookie who gets hurt and then Jones gets hurt and costs us 40 million. Then Mara fires everyone. Honestly I feel either way we are getting all new coaches and GM next year if we don't make the playoffs lol

I agree QB is more important but as I see it there are only two QBs who are actually an upgrade over Jones day 1 and that's Williams and Daniels. Maye, McCarthy are like Jones 2.0 they need teams to be built around them to be able to learn how to play and be successful as rookie QBs. However due to the lack of starting QBs in the NFL they will go high albeit to the wrong situations. We don't have the team for either of these guys and we will be in the same situation as we are with Jones in the next 5 years. Penix would fit into the same tier as Williams and Daniels but his injury history scares me more than Jones. Now if we drafted Joe Alt and then Penix, that would ease concerns. I'd just much rather draft a tier one type player at a position say DE, WR or OT than a tier two type of QB at #6. When we could still get.one of those tier two guys later.

I assumed they were gonna address the position regardless since he only played what? 11 games last year. Guess waiting it out doesn't hurt since if he retires his cap hit is substantially less if I read correctly. Shame too the guy can clearly get open when he plays, he just doesn't play much lol

Hey I think a team should draft a QB ever year even a late round pick. You never know if you get the next Brady. However as I said I'm not a draft nerd but im willing to bet more OTs work out than QBs in the draft.

4.27 speed should get anyone a roster spot regardless of talent. Hope he works out, could be a ridiculous return guy with the new kick off rules. Side note, the wifey works for the government in child foster care since we moved. Some of the situations she's talked about makes really highlights how limiting it is for any child to get out of that type of system. Good luck to the kid.

If that's the attitude why even bother drafting? In all super seriousness business tho, not sure if the stats have been delved into but I'm willing to say that any position pick within the top 10 is significantly much more likely to work out than a QB in the top 10. However the repercussions of missing on a QB set the franchise back longer than missing on another position. But just opinion l, I'm sure some draft nerd has done the research on it.

And trust me being done with Jones for the past two years, I want no I need to see a new QB in blue next year. But I don't want to pass up the talent that is there at #6 with a roster as void of talent as the Giants are.

Also with all the draft talk, the Giants will not take a QB at #6 unless for some freak reason they land Williams or Daniels falls. They ain't taking Maye or McCarthy at #6 However I can see them aggressively trading back up into the first if McCarthy drops or Penix is there near the end of round 1. There is way way to many NFL ready day one guys there at #6 to take one of the "tier two QBs" Williams and Daniels are ready to play day one, after that the otherr QBs (outside of Penix but that's a whole other can of worms) are all project type QBs. They need a team around them to be successful and learn. We don't have that team. But with the #6 we fill a massive need and beat play talent wise there to becoming that team. He it Nabers, or Alt, or Rome, or that CB.

I'd have no problem with Joe Alt dude is a 12 year starting tackle in the NFL. The QB in round 2 would actually have a real Oline. Something we haven't seen since 2009.

Well I mean he could sit out or just outright refuse to play, wasting the Giants pick and a year of his pro career. If we truly didn't like whatever made up situation these articles are trying to make it out to be. I just find it funny how suddenly Nabers is a head case a couple weeks before the draft. Probably the Giants putting shit out there hoping he falls.