I don't know man. I'm all for getting more pitching, but I just can't see giving up the farm for 1 guy that's gonna break the bank. I understand that he is probably the best pitcher in the league, but I also saw a bunch of stats that suggested that he faded down the stretch last season (I don't have a link).
It's impossible to know what we actually have as far as prospects go, but if Gomez and Martinez are actually what they are projected to be...man what an outfield. Gomez, Beltran, Martinez added in with the young talent of Wright and Reyes, That could be a good team for a long time.
I also don't know what Pelfrey and Humber will turn into. It would be nice to continue to develop the farm talent and keep a possible great team together for a long time rather than spend everything for 1 great pitcher.
Just my thoughts.