How much are we buying into this?

[Iceman_NYG]

Ok.....there have been rave reviews about Hagan being a blow-out and one of the biggest surprises of training camp. About him catching as many passes as all the others in the chart above him and also making the biggest plays.

 

How much are we buying into this? Does this alter the order? Or do we discard it as him probably playing against our 3rd defensive unit?

[Lughead]

Didn't we hear the same thing about moss last year in camp?

Seems to me a camp worrior does not equal a season long soilder . But we shall see in a few weeks

[Tempest]

I think Hagan has been a much better player than Moss has. I don't buy into Hagan becoming a mainstay on our WR core. Just wish the Giants had cut Moss last year instead of keeping him around to do nothing again this year.

[Treehugger]

I think he had a good camp last year too...also against the 3's.

[The P]

I think Hagan has been a much better player than Moss has. I don't buy into Hagan becoming a mainstay on our WR core. Just wish the Giants had cut Moss last year instead of keeping him around to do nothing again this year.

 

I pretty much agree with this.

[Nas]

I think he had a good camp last year too...also against the 3's.

 

So.. why not move up to play against hte 2s and the 1s?

[BIGBLUE01]

Derek Hagen......ARIZONA STATE BABY!!!! I love Derek Hagen from his Sun Devil days. Guy can produce if given time. We just have so many more better than him. He should be over Moss though, without a doubt.

[fishgutmartyr]

Hagan did well last training camp, too. But his real value is on special teams, as evidenced last season. I wouldn't hold my breath for him breaking into the starting lineup, though.

[JMFP]

Hagan might be the best receiver on the planet, but Sinorice Moss is irreplaceable....just like Tynes.