Toomer has made PLENTY of tough catches in Eli's career for Eli. As a matter of fact Toomer has been just about the only reciever making tough catches. See Denver (twice), see this year vs Chicago, see the Buffalo game....Toomer 5 for 99, Eli completed 5 out of 7 passes to Toomer.
...but when will we face it. Eli is Eli....not accurate, not a gunslinger, and definitely not a Giants Stadium QB a la Simms. And Eli has thrown some INTs that make me shake my head and say "What did he see that made him throw that pass?" Face it a tall Plax and incredible catches by Toomer has helped Eli be a little accurate.
Warner the QB for these Giants today???? OSI4THESACK....cut the bullshit!