I think you're exactly right, Eli and Amani actually have *gasp* chemistry. When Eli and Amani are on, not only is Amani one of the clutchest WRs in the league, Eli is one of the best quarterbacks.
I tried to explain this entire situation to an Eagles fan, but he claims that Mcnabb is still spot on even though he doesnt train with his WRs so it was a lost cause. He also claims that Burress is top 3 in the league at WR and that Manning is the problem not his supporting cast. I tried to tell him that while Manning has been far from perfect this season, if he had receivers that didn't give up mid route and actually played for their team as opposed to for themselves, he might be doing a lot better.