mastershake

https://www.nfl.com/games/cowboys-at-giants-2023-reg-1?active-tab=highlights Here are some pointed player observations. I don't need to say anything about Evan Neal since anyone watching knows he was a disaster, or the OL in general, but for the defense: - Kayvon Thibs continues to get bounced around and driven 3-7 yards down the field on running plays. No anchor whatseover; see the highlights above. Meanwhile, his pass rush still hasn't arrived. Similarly Ojulari as well. - Micah McFadden is a practice squad caliber player, who's playing ~75% of our defensive snaps. - Leonard Williams is a $32M cap hit, and he too was getting bounced around, and playing like backup/back of the roster type guy. - Jihan Ward: I don't get why the staff or anyone like this guy. - Adoree Jackson: Why did we move him to the slot, when he was doing great as an outside CB? That move seems to be ill advised so far.

So on WFAN, there was already a call this morning with a Giants fan calling to bench Daniel Jones and trade for QB Sam Ehlinger, hahahhahahhahhahaha

I still maintain it's an 8 or 9 win team. They're definitely going 0-4 vs the Eagles and Cowboys, and beyond that going 8-5 or 9-4 against the remaining comp at this point seems best case scenario. A 7-10 team also wouldn't surprise me. The Giants continue to insist on going into the season without a competent offensive line. We have a $40M QB, $12M RB, and a $10M TE....and it doesn't mean shit because the OL can't block, plus has penalties every set of downs.

Neal is looking like he's not there too, and Glowinski and Bredeson are playing like backups. In fact, as of today, the entire 2022 draft is looking pretty bad. As I was saying in the other thread, we're a 8 or 9 win team, but also 7 wins wouldn't shock me either.

https://www.reddit.com/r/NYGiants/comments/16fkpmn/bobby_skinner_the_giants_have_been_outscored_787/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb3x&utm_name=mweb3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

The Cards looked better than us today.

Another failed DG OL experiment!

So at 40-0 now (at home) I'm pretty sure this is the worst start to a season in franchise history now. I believe 1995 was the prior record for the worst one.

We're 3-7-1 in the last 11 games. Bring on the why we suck threads I say.

In 2012, we played the Cowboys in our first game, and lost by one TD 24-17.

Our offensive line is holding a competition to see if they can get more sacks vs more penalties tonight, and they're winning.

So it's fair to say our offensive scheme this year continues to be "Daniel, if your first read isn't there, just fucking take off and run for it."

To be fair, I could have gone with Nate Solder, Billy Price, Cam Fleming, Jon Halapio, Mike Remmers, Spencer Pulley, Chad Wheeler, and Patrick Omameh on that comparison, in terms of OL experiments we've tried the last 5 years.

In 1995, the Giants hosted the Cowboys at home in SNF after coming off a winning 9-7 season, similar to the record we had last year...and we got crushed 35-0. We finished 5-11 that year. Just sayin...

They're making me miss Will Hernandez and Matt Skura!

Sal Licata, I think, is pretty bad. I believe he was at one point a month or two ago claiming that the Yankees are still the best team in the AL, and will make it to the super bowl. Edit: I mean World Series. I can't even think straight tonight.

The NFL and networks really made a huge mistake by putting us on primetime TV tonight, and much of the season. Can't wait for us to get swapped out of Sunday Oct 15.

Bumping this thread since my predictions are playing out.

WFAN is going to be a shit show this week "What if we bring up that kid Tommy Devito from the practice squad...maybe see what he can do." "Do you think the Giant should try to trade up to take Caleb Williams?"

Arch Manning, 2026 baby!

There's some who still think we can go 1-5 against our division and still be legit contender 🤦‍♂️

Seriously take out Waller, Jones, and Barkley. Not worth it. The games over. Put in Tyrod, plus put in Hyatt and Gray let's see what the kids can do.

I'll be tuning out soon. The NFL really made a ratings mistake by putting us on primetime this week, and all these other weeks.

So far the Giants are looking like the worst team that played today

The patented Giants formula of going into the season without a competent OL continues.