mastershake

Were less than 24 hours from releasing Webb... are you sure theyve all passed on him? Meanwhile, this FO seeks to replace Tanney with McGloin lol

Youre back to thinking Tanney would perform better than Webb. Based on, hes been in the NFL. Participation trophy. Meanwhile, the giants FO is looking to dump your boy Tanney.

Today is the last day NFL teams can sign players? Lol The ones grasping at straws are those trying to claim Tanney is better than Webb. 32 teams passed on Tanney. Are you sure they will on Webb? Hell even this FO is looking to dump Tanney, lol

Clearly youve failed to read my posts. Go back and reread. You missed something. Speaking of not answering questions...You still havent answered several of mine. You mad?

Once again, youre back to thinking Tanney is better than Webb. Based on?

Fake news. Nice straw man

Now you think people are lined up against Lauletta? Lol

Says who?

I agree, you have to use your imagination to think Tanney is better.

McGloin actually has starting experience, unlike Tanney.

I find it hilarious that as you guys defend Tanney, the giants FO are currently looking at potentially replacing him with McGloin (a move I actually think is worthwhile).

Yeah bouncing around from several teams is a real credential.

Yeah youve made yourself very clear. You believe Tanney is as good as Webb, and has the same potential. Im just not buying it, so agree to disagree.

Youre conjecturing as much as anyone as well. You want to speculate on odds of developing a successful qb in the future? Here are your odds...Webb + Lauletta > Lauletta + Tanney, via the bulleted points I made earlier. Please tell me why Lauletta + Tanney is better odds. It again comes down to why Tanney over Webb? So far the rationale Ive heard so far is that Tanney is some kind of secret QB whisperer that will help Lauletta develop, which no one else knew about.

Many college QBs these days run non pro offenses. We can start listing successful QBs coming out of those offenses.

Why two young unproven QBs? How about why Tanney and one unproven QB? What if that one unproven QB (Lauletta) doesn't work out. Two unproven QBs has better developmental chances than one. Competition helps as well. Especially considering Eli has what, 2-3 years left? Is Tanney going to figure it out by age 33-34?

You keep saying what it was and wasnt...you dont know. What we know is they kept Tanney over Webb. Why? When has Tanney grasped NFL concepts? If hes there as a Jason Garrett type for Laulettas development, that logic makes sense, but Ill agree to disagree on the move.

By Tanneys age, Gannon has started nearly 40 games at that point. Whats Tanneys resume? If this has been a situation like choosing Lauletta and a starting capable vet over Webb, that logic makes sense.I just dont think you get any benefit with Tanney over Webb in terms of backup capability this year, theyd both probably perform about the same if thrust into the starting position...so given that they have equal backup capability, to me it then turns to a comparison on upside potential, where to me Tanney has less than Webb.

Now were back to insults.

He was a bystander over Webb...why?

No one said Webb was a certainty. Now youre putting words in peoples mouthes and arguing against stuff no one implied. Again, why Tanney over Webb?

Tanney is a bystander? Lol. It was Webb vs Lauletta? How do you know all of this? Lets examine what we know. Tanney was kept. Webb was not. The question is why Tanney over Webb. So far youve brought up Lauletta, and Tanney being a bystander.

Youre now comparing Lauletta to Webb, which is beside the point. Again, why Tanney over Webb? You wont read the case because you cant refute it and cant make the case for Tanney. Is Tanney a good fit? Is Tanney advanced enough? Blind adherence to anything the coach and GM decides...right cause no FO ever makes a personal mistake.

Im asking a very simple question. What is the rationale of keeping Tanney over Webb? So far all you have are insults and name calling Meanwhile, I put forth a case of why we should have kept Webb over Tanney.

You still cant explain why Tanney over Webb