RandolphScott

Pat Leonard is a terrible beat reporter. Also, this is still going on? LET IT GOOOOOOOO

He would have been picked up, easily.

Phil Simms is losing it. That guy def has CTE and not even bigelow green tea can save him

Well, the coach and GM did. They needed to see him actually play, I wont fault them for that. That would be dumb.

Lotsa armchair GMs in here. Send the Giants your resume. Tell them about your madden drafts and the 27 minutes you spend on YouTube watching highlights

Lauletta.

With the new CBA, def not enough snaps to go around to two developmental QBs. It all comes down to the fact that Tanney was never really in competition with Lauletta and Webb. The competition was between Lauletta and Webb. Did Tanney even get 2nd team snaps during camp? I didnt read anything that said that. No one is saying Tanney is Dan Marino has much as Mastershakes wants to put those words in my mouth. The fact of that matter is that the current regime believes that Lauletta is further along than Webb after training camp. Doesnt bode well for Webbs chances as hes not a rookie and yet the same mistakes keep coming up. Poor footwork and he looked highly uncomfortable out there. Even when he was playing fairly decent. Webb hasnt even been claimed by another NFL team yet. I have no doubt he will, but Im sure he will have an Alex Tanney like career.

Problem is, doesnt look like he can withstand a 16 game season. Hes a slight dude

Wouldn’t be opposed to Matt Moore. He could play well in a pinch.

But more like Herc said. The real move to question is Jonathan Stewart. You can see the fork in his back from the Moon....

24 hours after he was cut, future HOF and leader of the free world Davis Webb has gone unclaimed.

10 pages in and Vendetta is the equivalent of a 4 year old asking “but why” to every single thing you tell him/her.

I wish the Giants were in on Mack. Sucks we’re paying overrated Olivier, thankfully he’ll be gone after next off season.

Beckum would have been good under GASP. The Coughlin/MacAdoo system from 2014-2015. I mean, they got Larry Donnell 6 TDS and over 600 yards one season

Jerry Reese and Ben MacAdoo reach for a QB project and you guys get mad when a new regime comes in and cuts bait. Thats what new regimes do!

I think your gripe should be with Jerry Reese and Ben MacAdoo, Nas.

And they drafted Barkley because he was the best player in the draft. Period Davis Webb, a project QB prospect had nothing to do with the drafting of Barkley.

A new regime comes in and they draft a QB prospect they believe they can mold and be a starter down the line. News at 11.

This is a bizarre argument.

Yup, good call. Had one good half and Tore his achillies.

Replace Alex Tanney with Curtis Painter or Josh Johnson....

Instead there would be whining over the waste of a 4th round pick

I thought Matt Dodge was gonna be a star. Whoops!

Plus, Tanney never had competition. It was always Webb and Lauletta going for it. I dont understand why thats so hard to grasp.

I’m aware of that, Mastershake. Matt McGloin is pretty bad. I’ve never seen Tanney play but I have to imagine he’s better than McGloin