RandolphScott

Neal is a guard 

2 hours ago, BlueInCanada said:

Someone get this man a pan because this is a hot cake.

No it isn’t. He had a few good games in 2007 and he was ascending to the player he could have been but he was massively overrated.

On 5/4/2022 at 6:10 PM, Herc said:

I was a Sean Taylor guy.  That debate was so intense that year 

I did too. 
 

He didn’t exactly light the world on fire either. He was on his way but then was killed.

His biggest highlight is hitting a punter in a game that doesn’t even count. 

On 5/10/2022 at 4:52 PM, NeMesiS said:

Sean Taylor all the way. To me, he still the best safety to play the game. And this coming from a Emlen Tunnell fan. 

Lol. Sean Taylor had about a season of good games. He was overrated. 
 

On 12/25/2022 at 12:21 PM, Nas said:

Ditto on McKinney… the team is different when he’s playing.

Now this is so true.

He’s a difference maker in the secondary because he can go sideline to sideline. 
 

Julian Love is a good player but he isn’t X-Man 

That Eagles one broke me. 
 

Giants were getting their asses handed to them and they fought to come by down like 21 points to lose on a fucking 61 yard field goal. 

Mahomes

Allen

Burrow

Lamar Jackson

Herbert

TLaw

From a purely football stance, DeShawn Watson 

I’d take them all over Jones tomorrow. 

Daniel Jones struggles with reading defenses, that isn’t something that Eli Manning struggled with after 2007.

His first 3 full seasons he had alot of turnovers but he also had that “it” factor of coming from behind to win games. 
 

The only thing Jones has over Eli is his running ability. Numbers don’t tell the full story. 

You’re wrong. End of story. 
 

:-) 

You got diversify yo’ bonds 

40 minutes ago, CrazedDogs said:

Eh, different rules back then, very different offenses. No point in using completion percentage as a metric. I don’t see much point in comparing Eli and Jones either. Very different players.

and you remember the ‘is Eli elite’ saga completely different from me. I recall non Giants fans referring to Eli as a living breathing football IQ test; you could tell if someone understood football by their opinion on Eli. If they thought Eli was mediocre or worse, you knew right off it wasn’t someone who really understood how games are won and lost. 

Jones has as much or more physical potential than Eli, for sure. The comparison ends there. 

Daniel Jones playing in Gilbride’s offense would have been a downright disaster.

Yeah I’m not reading all that shit because it isn’t right. 

I’m happy but if the Giants can get a clear upgrade at QB then they should do it. 

Daniel Jones isn’t on the same hemisphere as Eli Manning. 

32 minutes ago, Herc said:

I think we can win with him if we improve the roster

I don’t know yet but I’d like to see this happen. 

34 minutes ago, jranieli said:

He's definitely earned a bridge deal. He's only 25. I don't think the Giants aren't in a position to draft a QB next year, especially with their record. 

What he said. 

Cohen just dropped his balls over the MLB.

I’m here for it 

Bozo penalty by a guy who won’t be on the team next season 

CC Brown

Eli Apple

Trey Junkin

William Joseph 

30 years old coming off two ACL tears and apparently still a dickhead.

Hard pass. Hopefully he loses in the divisional round with Dallas

3 hours ago, mastershake said:

The only part he forgot was accusing you of living in your mom's basement.

That would be difficult since my mom died! 

On 5/19/2014 at 12:58 PM, BleedinBlue said:

???? Who am I talking to, a 9th grade kid who wears his pants down below his ass, is failing class, and who thinks it's cool to respond to an adult with "dude".

 

If you disagree, posit a thought out response. If you have some inside information that proves that Kennard is not good, or isn't going to be good, then speak up like a man.

 

I don't like to waste time with children who think calling a man "dude" is some kind of appropriate response.

Dude! 

lol at thinking Parsons won’t be a cowboy for life 

On 11/14/2022 at 7:37 PM, Herc said:

Yeah I was in 233.  I saw one jersey directly below us and then like 4 leaving in the 3rd.  I saw a couple of Steelers too.  I always find it so weird to see that stuff 

I’d like a pivot table on which Steelers players jerseys were worn please as well as if it was the home color, away color and possible alternates.

plz

10 hours ago, Herc said:

Saw 1 stingley jersey and that’s it.  Bet you’re loving the % today 

Did you use the I AM AN ASS stats formula?