This idea that Eli only played two great games, only had a couple great passes, won because of flukes, or was never one if the top QBs for an extended period of time (most naysayers say around 5 years) is complete bullshit.
From 12-2007 through the 2012 season, Eli was an absolute stud and, at a minimum, top 5 QB in the league. He had the wins, come from behind victories, the stats, the SB trophies, and the SB MVPs. After the 2012 season, his stats were still very good and he was still a top 10 QB for a few more years.
The stat compiler argument is horseshit too. If it's so damn easy, why don't more QBs do it? Will Eli eventually get knocked out of the top 10 in stats? Sure... probably a decade or two or three from now with current arena league rules.
Eli was fucking awesome. My fav offensive player ever and, without a doubt, a HOFer. Fuck the jealous naysayers. Eli, I love you man.