I'm not sure those numbers hold true when its a top athlete, and a surgery performed by a top surgeon.
No clue who did Penix's surgery or about how severe his injury was, I'm just saying in general that my ACL repair as a 40 something weekend warrior, performed by the neighborhood ortho (which is mostly where those stats will come from, not a handful of top athletes), isn't the same thing as a heisman contending college football star.
I'd want to take a close look at it, but I'm not scared off by a few surgeries. Not these days. Hell, give the guy a Tommy John and put another five yards on his deep ball.