osi724dasack

Finnegan

I like it. He stood up for himself. Fine ban, Norman and others were roughing ODB up but he fucked with them and ended up in thier heads at the end of the day. Too bad we came up short.

Brent Alexander was good p2 he was solid for us

Omar Stoutmire. Now that's a mean safety. Lol Aron Rouse was pretty bad even tho he was crazy tall and fast

I key in on the safety's many times and safety was my favorite position by far on defense to play. Loved that position and I admire many past and present safety's, it's evolved the past 7-12 years so much in the NFL

And cut Safety Brandon Merriweather Fyi

Hate to be a Debbie downer buttt.... Cooper Taylor sucks, so do all our safety's especially Craig Dahl. Haven't seen much of Taylor but he's just soft, slow, and lacks instincts. One of the worst safety's I've seen on an NFL roster, he can't even tackle or stay healthy. Craig Dahl, has average size and tackling ability, with slightly above average football IQ, however he has the athleticism of the average NFL punter and he's probly the worst athlete the Giants have ever had at Safety in the modern era. Even our 2009 safety's were better. Everyone else is Injured Collins looks OK so far, I tend to believe he will improve a lot when he gets more help beside him. He's got good size and decent speed but his tackling also has looked below average compared to guys like Rolle, Phillips, Grant but Collins shows good solid starter ability for sure, maybe even a few pro bowl caliber seasons. Currently tho he's JAG. Merriweather, he's our 2nd best safety, he also sucks. He's basically A better version of Craig Dahl and can run considerably better. Hits hard as hell atleast.

Just take it all back man! It's ok you can and it'll be ok and I inderstand. Eli's just too good, so I'd odell. I jerked off after watching this http://www.nfl.com/videos/new-york-giants/0ap3000000602061/Dottino-Beckham-and-Manning-made-up-their-own-special-play

Eli systematically raped and pillaged every single dolphin defender last night.

Let's Go baby lets GO!!! 27-23 Giants!

Cowboys, Bengals, Ravens, Jets, Bills, Raiders are all teams that might sign him Tuesday

Thanks for posting

I hate his 2 yard tackle dances when we are losing

Rumor is the reason he got cut was he got into it with the almighty Markus Kuhn

Beat me to it Big mistake. I would have benched him and given him another chance. He's only 23. That said I'm not that concerned about him, he wasn't ever gonna be a B+ or better end/pass rusher at most

Team cut him.. Guy was in time for a team meeting instead of 5 mins early

I want Nicks to start over Randle but that's just my dabbed out opinion

I blame a few things 1.) Reuben Randle 2.) The O Line Needs more time and 1-2 more pieces (starter and vet backup) Beatty 1 more shot. 3.) Victor Cruz That's offense 1.) Jon Beason / Reese 2.) JPP situation 3.) the safety's / Reese (Colllins looks average so far, but I beleive in him) That said everyone stays put for another year, let Reese make the final touches on the OLine and use the cap room he created. I'm confident Reese/Coughlin can snag another top flight #2 WR to compliment Beckham in a number of situations. They have both showed incredible eyes for talent at this position over the last decade.

Nassib is not the answer. If the Giants get mathematically eliminated from postseason I would consider sitting Eli a 2nd half blowout Andy trying to boost any trade value he may have.

Dibs if p2 can't go. Haha yo if it's 2 tickets and p2 gets them you should make him go with me and meet me at the stadium hahah

Not a true mathematical solution you just displayed. Your wrong 2011 we had the 32nd ranked rushing attack and we were bottom half of the league in most defensive category's. Made the playoffs. Also won some playoff games

You make an excellent point. However that said I have no issue keeping the guy around

Lmao at the wife's opinion thing lol. I can relate to that a little as well.

Like I've said the guys usually one of the better Giants posters here but he's currently in a crisis and needs to take a walk and smoke a pack of cigs. I love Jim, again great poster, but his opinions Eli and now Nassib just seem like a hyperbolic reaction from an otherwise knowledgable fan. I agree tho, it was a jackstroud esq statement and yes a normal sane fan. Eli is still elite. That's It. Case closed. We haven't made the playoffs in 5 years for a number of reasons. Eli isn't why.

I agree man, it's pathetic. We have a guy like Odell and we can't close out these games! I'm officially FUCKING SICK OF REUBEN FUCKING PUSSY ASS RANDLE! Guy is a total fucking loser ass scrub who just complained to the media about his role. Let's keep Odell healthy, draft a WR, sign a fuckin wr (maybe Jeffrey) and see if cruz can mix in as well and give it another shot next yeAR. RANDLE JUST HASNT PROGRESSED AND LOOKS LIKE SHIT, HES THE NUMBER 2 and he plays like the number 4-5. It's fucking pathetic especially when ODB is drawing triple coverage on the opposite side of the field on a regular basis