61 replies to this topic

[Virginia Giant]

I'm going Frank Reich as HC and Rosen as the draft selection.

[UK-Giantsfan]

McDaniels and trade down for multiple picks

[Nas]

A toss up between Shurmer and Reich... (selected Shurmer)... and Barkley for RB (despite really wanting Rosen but I like Webb)

[Gorilla]

Be nice to trade down to either the Broncos or the Jets depending who will pay more and taking the top Left Tackle in the first round.

 

If they do end up going with a QB in the first round, I think they need to see if Eli can get traded, maybe to Jacksonville....   after watching them play yesterday, they are competent QB away from a Superbowl run

[Sephiroth]

Where's Bill Cowher? 

[BlueInCanada]

Shurmur and Barkley.

Giants set franchise record for most points per game and points on a season.

9-7 and a trip to the wild card round.

[Drizzle]

This thread should get way more love. Nice work, VG.

Btw, Barkley and McDaniels.

[Sephiroth]

I like Reich and trade down. 

[Virginia Giant]

A toss up between Shurmer and Reich... (selected Shurmer)... and Barkley for RB (despite really wanting Rosen but I like Webb)

Shurmur is interesting, I wouldn't hate it if he signed. I think that offense does have more weapons than most though. I like Reich because I've heard he gets a lot of credit for Wentz's progression and that offense was stellar.

[Virginia Giant]

McDaniels and trade down for multiple picks

The more I think about it, the less I see trading down happening. There's probably 4 or 5 first round qbs this year, ava while there are a lot of teams looking to draft them, I don't see a big return unless a team like the Broncos really falls in love with Rosen of Mayfield enough to give up the house to move up.

[Virginia Giant]

Where's Bill Cowher? 

He's taken himself out of the running hasn't he? Others may have as well, pulled these names from a few different websites.

[Virginia Giant]

I like Reich and trade down. 

Trade down for qb or bpa?

[Virginia Giant]

This thread should get way more love. Nice work, VG.

Btw, Barkley and McDaniels.

If Webb is a franchise qb, Barkley is the way to go. But I don't know much about what offensive line talent is in the draft.

If we can coax the jets into giving up a 1 st in the next year or two, I'd be more comfortable trading down because that pick is likely to be much higher than the Broncos.

[BlueInCanada]

The latest HC news according to NFL.com

 

 

New York Giants

 

The Giants have requested to interview Eagles defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz. If granted, the interview would have to wait until Philadelphia's season is over. The Giants interviewed Patriots offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels and Patriots defensive coordinator Matt Patricia on Friday. Both were interviewed in Foxborough, Massachusetts, by Giants president John Mara, general manager Dave Gettleman, and assistant general manager Kevin Abrams, the threesome conducting the initial interviews. Giants chairman Steve Tisch will meet with the candidates later in the process.

The Giants are scheduled to interview Panthers defensive coordinator Steve Wilks on Tuesday. New York interviewed its interim head coach Steve Spagnuolo. The team interviewed Vikings offensive coordinator Pat Shurmur and former Broncos assistant head coach Eric Studesville.

 

Good news is that the Bears hired someone named Nugget or something, and they were supposedly really interested in McDaniels as well. so that leaves one last landing spot for him.

[Virginia Giant]

I just can't get passed the Patriot's coordinator failures once they leave that organization.  Maybe there is something different about McDaniels, but guys like Weiss we've been here before with Weisss and Romeo, and maybe some others.  Not too worried about McDaniels Broncos tenure, a lot of 1st time coaches don't have great starts, but Bill drives the Pats, no matter his assistants or QB. 

 

Reich feels like an up and coming coach that is going to have a lot of success.

[NeMesiS]

I keep seeing rumors of Bill coming back to the Giants.

[Nas]

I just can't get passed the Patriot's coordinator failures once they leave that organization.  Maybe there is something different about McDaniels, but guys like Weiss we've been here before with Weisss and Romeo, and maybe some others.  Not too worried about McDaniels Broncos tenure, a lot of 1st time coaches don't have great starts, but Bill drives the Pats, no matter his assistants or QB. 

 

Reich feels like an up and coming coach that is going to have a lot of success.

 

I too don't think too much of the Patriots' coordinators... there's just so much success mainly because of Belicheck...

[fringe]

 

I too don't think too much of the Patriots' coordinators... there's just so much success mainly because of Belicheck...

Right, we should only look at OC's whose teams have had little success and awful head coaches. Those guys know their stuff! ;0)

[Nas]

Right, we should only look at OC's whose teams have had little success and awful head coaches. Those guys know their stuff! ;0)

 

Yes... that's almost kindda maybe what I said.  Sorta. 

[echochamber]

I keep seeing rumors of Bill coming back to the Giants.

Where there is smoke there's fire. It will happen

[Herc]

Where there is smoke there's fire. It will happen

Couldnt agree more. The longer the team waits to hire a coach the more likely it is that belichick leaked this all as a signal to the giants. Brady/kraft/bill arent going to confirm the story and they cant no comment it so their bare minimum denials over the last few days mean nothing

[CrazedDogs]

I wouldn't even be mad if they give up the 2nd overall. Wouldn't personally go that far, but if you have a chance to get the greatest coach of all time, you do it.

[bigblue25]

Seems its leaning towards what I said from the beginning Wilks with DeFilippo has OC

[BlueInCanada]

Seems its leaning towards what I said from the beginning Wilks with DeFilippo has OC

 

Well I guess drafting top 10 for the next few years will help us get Eli's replacement. 

[Virginia Giant]

If we can get Bill, it's worth the 2nd overall.  I would trust Webb's ability to succeed in Bill's system.