You're the Coach.

[Nesta]

[fishgutmartyr]

Volek because he learned under McNair, and by all accounts, is a competent QB. Young just isn't ready yet, and unless they toss the whole season under a bus, then he's not the best choice.

 

I picked Grossman because his problem isn't his ability, it's staying on the field. Griese has had his chances, and proven that he's a mediocrity.

 

Kitna has some ability. He's shown he can be a starter in Cincinnati, but wasn't kept because they have Palmer. He's like the prototype for Drew Brees, where the light turns on for a QB, but the team has already given up on him and drafted a QB high.

[ccase39]

dont put much stock in my votes im not one of those coaches. i just thought it would be funny to vote in that pole and make you believe i was one of those coaches

[Herc]

wow im the only one who voted mccown? i like kitna too, but i don't think we've seen the best from mccown yet, i still think of that last game of the season two years ago when he drove the cardinals down the field to beat the vikings

[rawRen1]

Vince Young >> Because Billy Volek is not all that!

 

Brian Griese >> Because Grossman is, well, he's Rex Grossman. And I think Griese is far more talented.

 

Jon Kitna >> He's an above average QB, and the other guy is not very good!